Navigating the complexities of PCI DSS (Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard) compliance can be daunting, especially when it comes to vulnerability scanning. A critical component of PCI DSS compliance is utilizing an Approved Scanning Vendor (ASV) to conduct external vulnerability scans. The PCI Security Standards Council (PCI SSC) lists 85 ASV companies, predominantly based in the U.S., with many offering global services. With such a wide array of choices, selecting the right Asv Scan Tool for your organization’s needs can be challenging. This guide will delve into top ASV providers and key considerations to help you make an informed decision.
Some ASV companies are recognized names in the cybersecurity industry due to their broader security product portfolios. Here are some of the well-known and highly regarded ASV providers:
#1. Qualys PCI ASV Scan Tool
Product: Qualys PCI
Qualys stands out as a leading vulnerability management platform, established in 1999 and serving over 10,000 subscription customers across more than 130 countries. Their strategic alliances with major cloud providers like Microsoft Azure, AWS, and Google Cloud underscore their robust and scalable infrastructure. The Qualys PCI asv scan tool is a part of their comprehensive suite, offering seamless integration and a unified security approach.
Pros
- US-based with global reach
- Cloud-native platform
- User-friendly and customizable dashboard
- Unlimited on-demand scans for flexibility
- Comprehensive suite of security services beyond ASV scanning
- Flexible scan scheduling to minimize disruption
- Dedicated customer support
- Strong industry reputation and high user ratings
Cons
- Pricing can be per IP address, potentially scaling costs with larger networks
#2. Sectigo HackerGuardian ASV Scan Tool
Product: HackerGuardian
Sectigo, primarily known as a leading Certificate Authority, brings its extensive experience in digital security to its HackerGuardian asv scan tool. With over 700,000 businesses utilizing their platform, Sectigo offers a trusted and established solution, particularly valuable for organizations prioritizing certificate management alongside PCI compliance.
Pros
- UK-based option, advantageous for European entities concerning data residency
- Unlimited on-demand scans for continuous security assessment
- Flexible scan scheduling to accommodate operational needs
- Responsive customer support
- Competitive pricing
- Global service coverage
Cons
- Lacks a security trust seal, which some organizations may prefer for public assurance
#3. Tenable.io PCI ASV Service 2022
Product: Tenable.io PCI ASV Service 2022
Tenable, founded in 2002, boasts over 40,000 customers globally. Their Nessus vulnerability scanner is widely recognized as a leading application in the industry. The Tenable.io PCI asv scan tool leverages this powerful scanning engine, providing a robust and reliable solution for PCI DSS compliance.
Pros
- US-based with global service delivery
- Cloud-based platform for scalability and accessibility
- Strong reputation built on Nessus vulnerability scanner
- High user ratings reflecting customer satisfaction
- Dedicated customer support
Cons
- Scan schedule flexibility may be less granular compared to some competitors
- Pricing model can be per IP, which might be a concern for large IP ranges
#4. GM Security Technologies FirstFire v1.4 ASV Scan Tool
Product: FirstFire v1.4
GM Sectec brings over 50 years of IT and technology experience to the cybersecurity domain. Their FirstFire v1.4 asv scan tool is part of a broader suite of services focused on cybersecurity, governance, and compliance. Operating in over 50 countries, GM Sectec offers a global perspective with a strong emphasis on managed security services.
Pros
- US-based company
- Employs deep learning for enhanced vulnerability detection accuracy
- Integrated service offering encompassing vulnerability management, PCI ASV, and Attack Surface Management
- Cloud-based architecture for accessibility and scalability
- Supports multiple scanning types, including active, agent-based, passive, and cloud connectors
Cons
- Pricing transparency may be limited, requiring direct inquiry for cost details
#5. Optiv PCI ASV Scanning Portal
Product: PCI ASV Scanning Portal
Optiv distinguishes itself with a more hands-on approach to security. They emphasize partnership and collaboration, working closely with clients to manage cyber risk and develop tailored security programs. Their PCI ASV Scanning Portal is supported by consultative services, making it a strong choice for organizations seeking guided compliance.
Pros
- US-based provider
- Unlimited scanning capability
- Personalized 1:1 ASV setup consulting to ensure proper configuration
- Comprehensive catalog of related PCI services, simplifying compliance management
- Strong industry reputation
- Expertise across diverse cybersecurity domains and industries
Cons
- Pricing details are not readily available, requiring direct contact for quotation
#6. SAINT ASV Solution
Product: SAINT ASV Solution
SAINT Corporation, a veteran-owned small business based in Maryland, US, focuses on serving Federal Agencies with managed security services. Their SAINT asv scan tool provides essential vulnerability scanning and penetration testing capabilities, particularly appealing to organizations prioritizing US-based vendors and government-focused solutions.
Pros
- Offers both internal and external network vulnerability scanning
- Provides internal and external penetration testing services
- Includes remediation assistance to guide vulnerability resolution
Cons
- Feature set may be less extensive compared to larger platforms
- Limited online information regarding product features and details
- Pricing is not publicly disclosed
#7. SecureWorks Managed Vulnerability Services – PCI
Product: Managed Vulnerability Services – PCI
SecureWorks operates globally in over 75 countries, offering hands-on cybersecurity services, including incident response and managed security solutions. Their Managed Vulnerability Services – PCI provides a comprehensive approach to ASV scanning, backed by their extensive security expertise.
Pros
- No internal software deployment required, simplifying implementation
- SAQ (Self-Assessment Questionnaire) support to aid PCI compliance efforts
- Remediation advice provided based on scan results to facilitate vulnerability resolution
Cons
- Scanning frequency limits are not specified, requiring clarification for high-frequency scanning needs
- Pricing information is not publicly available
#8. SecurityMetrics ASV Scan II
Product: SecurityMetrics ASV Scan II
SecurityMetrics is a well-recognized name in cybersecurity, having received over 38 industry awards since 2010. Their SecurityMetrics ASV Scan II asv scan tool offers a user-friendly interface and a focus on accuracy and efficient scan management.
Pros
- Self-managed interface for convenient scan scheduling
- Improved organization of scan data for easier analysis
- Flexible scanning schedule options
- Exportable results in various formats (PDF, Excel) for reporting and documentation
- Continuous efforts to reduce false positives, improving scan accuracy
Cons
- Unknown scanning frequency limitations
- Pricing details are not publicly advertised
Understanding the Differences Among ASV Scan Tools
While the PCI SSC’s ASV Program Requirements ensure a baseline level of service, distinctions exist among asv scan tools and their providers. These differences often lie in the specific needs they cater to.
Variations can include geographic focus (US vs. Europe-centric operations), industry specialization, and the range of supplementary services offered. Defining your organization’s specific ASV requirements is crucial in narrowing down the optimal choice.
Key questions to consider when evaluating asv scan tool providers:
- Does the ASV company have experience serving my industry?
- Does the ASV company adequately support my geographic locations? (Most cloud-based ASVs offer global service reach).
- Where is the ASV company headquartered, and what data privacy laws are applicable?
- What is included in the ASV service pricing structure?
- Does my organization require just scanning, or do we need vulnerability scanning and detection capabilities combined?
- Do we need an ASV company that supports application scanning in addition to network scanning?
Clearly defining your organization’s ASV service requirements is the essential first step in selecting the most suitable asv scan tool.
Key Considerations for Choosing Your ASV Scan Tool
The PCI SSC’s ASV program simplifies vendor vetting, but choosing from numerous options can still be complex. Pricing is a significant factor, particularly for small to medium-sized organizations where PCI compliance costs can be a substantial concern. However, if scan quality is paramount, opting for established and reputable asv scan tool providers listed earlier is advisable.
Beyond pricing, consider these crucial factors during your ASV vendor selection process. These considerations should align with your vendor due diligence practices and help you refine your ASV vendor shortlist.
Organization’s Security Posture
Assess your organization’s size, security maturity, and regulatory landscape to determine the level of ASV technical support required. Organizations with mature security teams may require less support, while those with less in-house expertise might prioritize robust technical assistance from their asv scan tool provider.
ASV Company Customer Support & Staff Experience
Responsive and knowledgeable customer support is invaluable. A 24/7/365 support team can ensure smooth vulnerability management. Experienced ASV staff can offer valuable recommendations for vulnerability remediation, enhancing your security posture.
Scanning and Re-scanning Flexibility
Evaluate whether the asv scan tool offers unlimited scanning or per-scan billing. Frequent scanning is vital for staying ahead of emerging vulnerabilities. Unlimited scanning can be cost-effective for organizations prioritizing continuous security monitoring. Per-scan billing might be suitable if you use other non-ASV scanners for routine checks and reserve the ASV tool specifically for PCI compliance scans.
Additional Service Offerings
Beyond asv scan tool services, explore if the vendor offers complementary services like application vulnerability scanning, penetration testing, or incident response. Bundling services might lead to cost savings and streamline vendor management. If you already utilize a vendor like Qualys for vulnerability management, their PCI ASV offering might be a natural and efficient choice.
Geographic Alignment
Ensure the ASV company’s geographic service coverage aligns with your organization’s operational footprint—local, national, or global. Global organizations should prioritize ASVs with proven global service delivery capabilities for faster and more efficient scanning across all locations.
Scan Scheduling Flexibility
Consider an asv scan tool that provides granular control over scan scheduling. The ability to schedule scans during off-peak hours minimizes potential performance impacts on production systems.
Cloud-Based Scanning Capabilities
As cloud adoption grows, a cloud-based asv scan tool can significantly accelerate scanning processes, especially for cloud-native environments.
Ultimately, any PCI SSC-listed ASV company will enable PCI DSS ASV compliance. When uncertain, leaning towards established cybersecurity vendors is a safe approach. However, if a lesser-known ASV vendor better aligns with your specific operational needs, consider evaluating them thoroughly.
Remember that vendor selection is not static. As your organization evolves, so might your ASV requirements. Annually, during your PCI scoping exercises, reassess your asv scan tool vendor to ensure they remain the optimal choice for your current PCI CDE landscape. If your needs have outgrown your current vendor, revisit these evaluation criteria to find a better fit.
