The NGS scan tool, while once a mainstay for Ford vehicle diagnostics, faces limitations with newer Controller Area Network (CAN) communication protocols introduced in 2003. This has naturally led automotive technicians and enthusiasts to seek more versatile and future-proof alternatives. Are there effective replacements for the NGS scan tool that offer broader capabilities and better value? The answer is a resounding yes, and Ford themselves have paved the way towards these advanced solutions.
Understanding the NGS Scan Tool and its Constraints
The original NGS (New Generation Star Tester) was a dedicated scan tool designed for earlier Ford models. However, its architecture wasn’t built to fully support the CAN protocol, which became standard in newer vehicles. This meant the NGS started to lose its comprehensive diagnostic abilities on these modern systems. While Ford offered an NGS+ upgrade by incorporating a Vehicle Communication Module (VCM) adapter, this was more of a patch than a complete overhaul. The industry recognized the need for more adaptable and powerful diagnostic tools.
Ford’s Transition to Modular Diagnostic Tools: VCM and Beyond
Recognizing the evolving landscape of vehicle technology, Ford strategically shifted towards a modular diagnostic approach. This involved developing new hardware and software designed to be more flexible and compatible with future vehicle communication systems. The core of this new strategy revolves around two key hardware components:
-
Vehicle Communication Module (VCM): This device acts as the central communication interface for all Ford vehicles via the diagnostic link. The VCM is designed to be universally compatible with Ford diagnostic software, representing a cornerstone of their modular approach. It provides access to a suite of software applications, making it a versatile tool.
-
Vehicle Measurement Module (VMM): Launched later, the VMM is responsible for physical measurements like fuel pressure and acts as a digital volt-ohm meter (DVOM). Working in conjunction with the VCM, the VMM expands the diagnostic capabilities to include more dynamic and in-depth testing.
These hardware modules are complemented by a range of software solutions, effectively presenting viable alternatives to the standalone NGS scan tool:
-
NGS+ (NGS plus CAN): As mentioned, this was an interim solution to extend the life of the NGS for CAN-equipped vehicles. By adding a VCM adapter, the NGS+ could handle basic CAN diagnostics, but it was still limited compared to newer systems.
-
Portable Diagnostic Software (PDS): PDS is designed to run on Pocket-PC devices in conjunction with the VCM. This combination offers a more advanced scan tool functionality than NGS+, providing greater portability and enhanced diagnostic features.
-
Integrated Diagnostic Software (IDS): IDS represents Ford’s move towards a PC-based diagnostic platform. Effectively replacing the older Workshop Diagnostic System (WDS), IDS leverages the power of a standard PC and utilizes both the VCM and VMM. This system provides a comprehensive diagnostic environment, integrating access to both diagnostic functions and service information on a single machine. IDS is well-suited for tackling complex diagnostic challenges and intermittent issues.
The Rise of PC-Based Diagnostic Solutions
Ford’s adoption of IDS highlights a broader industry trend: the shift towards PC-based diagnostic tools. This approach offers numerous advantages, including:
- Enhanced Processing Power and Memory: PCs provide significantly more processing power and memory compared to dedicated handheld scan tools, enabling faster diagnostics and the ability to handle complex data.
- Software Flexibility and Updates: PC-based systems allow for easier software updates and upgrades via the internet, ensuring technicians always have access to the latest diagnostic information and capabilities. Ford’s software delivery system for VCM-compatible software emphasizes internet-based updates.
- Integration with Service Information: As seen with IDS, PC platforms can seamlessly integrate diagnostic software with repair manuals, wiring diagrams, and other crucial service information, streamlining the diagnostic and repair process.
Exploring Aftermarket Alternatives
While Ford’s VCM, VMM, PDS, and IDS represent the OEM path forward, the aftermarket also offers a wide array of alternatives to the NGS scan tool. Many reputable aftermarket scan tool manufacturers provide tools that are compatible with Ford vehicles and often offer broader vehicle coverage, supporting multiple makes and models. These aftermarket tools can range from handheld devices to PC-based systems and often provide comparable or even enhanced functionality at various price points.
When considering aftermarket options, it’s crucial to research tools that specifically advertise Ford vehicle compatibility and CAN protocol support. Look for features like:
- Comprehensive Code Reading and Clearing: Ability to read and clear diagnostic trouble codes (DTCs) across all vehicle systems.
- Live Data Streaming: Real-time monitoring of sensor data and parameters.
- Actuation Tests: Capability to activate components for testing purposes.
- Bi-directional Controls: Advanced functions to command and control vehicle systems.
- Special Functions: Support for specific procedures like key programming, module programming, and system calibrations.
Conclusion: Embracing Modern Diagnostic Technology
The NGS scan tool, while historically significant, is no longer the optimal solution for diagnosing modern Ford vehicles, especially those utilizing CAN protocols. Ford’s strategic shift to VCM-based modular tools and PC-based software like IDS offers a clear upgrade path. Furthermore, the aftermarket provides a diverse range of alternatives, empowering technicians and enthusiasts to choose diagnostic solutions that best meet their needs and budgets. By embracing these modern diagnostic technologies, professionals and DIYers can effectively troubleshoot and repair today’s complex automotive systems.
