Modern vehicles are complex systems, heavily reliant on electronic controls and sophisticated software. Diagnosing issues in these vehicles without the right tools can be incredibly challenging, akin to a doctor trying to treat a patient who cannot communicate. In today’s automotive landscape, a scan tool is not just helpful—it’s indispensable for effective diagnosis and repair.
For automotive professionals, understanding how to utilize a scan tool is paramount. However, even before mastering its operation, a more fundamental question arises: Choosing An Automotive Scan Tool that best fits your needs. Navigating the vast array of options can be daunting, a sentiment echoed in countless discussions within professional automotive forums. While the ideal scan tool is subjective and varies depending on individual requirements, establishing general guidelines for purchase is entirely feasible. Let’s explore the primary categories of scan tools to clarify your choices.
Understanding Automotive Scan Tool Categories
The landscape of automotive scan tools includes a variety of categories, each designed with specific functionalities and applications in mind. Understanding these distinctions is the first step in choosing an automotive scan tool that aligns with your diagnostic needs.
Code Readers
At the most basic level, we have code readers. These are entry-level tools designed for one primary function: retrieving diagnostic trouble codes (DTCs). While limited in features compared to more advanced options, code readers are invaluable for quickly identifying basic issues flagged by the vehicle’s onboard diagnostic system. They are the simplest and most affordable entry point into electronic diagnostics, making them useful for quick checks and preliminary assessments.
OBD I Scanners
For vehicles manufactured before 1996, OBD I scanners are necessary. The era of OBD I was characterized by a lack of standardization. Each vehicle manufacturer employed different diagnostic connectors, locations, communication protocols, and terminologies. OBD I scanners were therefore often manufacturer-specific or adaptable through various adapters and software. While less common in modern workshops focusing on newer vehicles, OBD I tools remain essential for servicing classic and older models. Some versatile OBD I scanners could be upgraded to handle the newer OBD II standards, offering a bridge between the older and newer diagnostic systems.
OBD II Generic Scanners
The introduction of OBD II in 1996 marked a significant shift towards standardization in automotive diagnostics. All vehicles from 1996 onwards were required to have a standardized 16-pin diagnostic connector (DLC) located within a specified area of the vehicle. Furthermore, key diagnostic parameters, known as Parameter IDs (PIDs), were also standardized. This standardization paved the way for OBD II generic scanners. These tools could communicate with any OBD II compliant vehicle, regardless of manufacturer, using a single, universal connector. OBD II generic scanners provide access to standardized PIDs, allowing technicians to read generic diagnostic codes, clear codes, and check emissions monitors across a wide range of vehicles. This universality made them a fundamental tool in any automotive repair shop.
OBD II Enhanced Scanners
Building upon the foundation of OBD II generic capabilities, enhanced scanners offer a deeper level of diagnostic access. These tools go beyond the standardized PIDs and incorporate manufacturer-specific PIDs, unlocking a wealth of additional data and control functions. OBD II enhanced scanners often include bidirectional controls, enabling technicians to command certain vehicle functions to activate for testing purposes. Furthermore, many enhanced scanners expand their diagnostic reach beyond the powertrain system to cover other critical vehicle systems like ABS, airbag (SRS), suspension, and air conditioning. This expanded coverage makes enhanced scanners significantly more powerful for comprehensive vehicle diagnostics. When choosing an automotive scan tool for professional use, an enhanced OBD II scanner is often considered a minimum requirement for handling diverse diagnostic tasks.
Factory Scan Tools
At the pinnacle of diagnostic capability are factory scan tools, also known as OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) tools. Designed and used by vehicle manufacturers and their dealerships, factory tools offer the most comprehensive diagnostic and programming capabilities for a specific vehicle brand. These tools provide access to the highest number of PIDs, the most extensive bidirectional controls, and the deepest coverage of all vehicle systems within a particular make. Factory tools are unparalleled for in-depth diagnostics, complex repairs, and module programming. While they typically come with a higher price tag and are brand-specific, factory tools are indispensable for specialists focusing on particular vehicle brands and for tackling the most challenging diagnostic scenarios. For workshops specializing in a specific brand, investing in a factory scan tool is often essential to provide the highest level of service.
In-Depth Look at OBD II Scan Tool Types
Within the OBD II category, both generic and enhanced tools offer distinct advantages depending on the specific needs of the technician and the nature of the diagnostic work. When choosing an automotive scan tool, consider how these nuances align with your typical workflow.
OBD II Generic: Speed and Efficiency
For technicians prioritizing speed and efficiency, particularly when dealing with 1996 and newer vehicles, OBD II generic tools are often the preferred starting point. Many of these tools are designed for plug-and-play simplicity. This means minimal setup time – no need to select vehicle connection cables or manually input the Vehicle Identification Number (VIN) before accessing basic OBD II data. With a quick connection, technicians can swiftly read and clear diagnostic codes, and check system monitors. This rapid access can save significant time, especially when compared to more feature-rich “power box” scanners that may require more elaborate setup procedures.
The efficiency of OBD II generic tools was highlighted by an engine control engineer from a major automotive manufacturer, who noted that a simple, pocket-sized OBD II generic scan tool allowed him to accomplish “80% of my diagnostics in 10% of the time” on new vehicles. Their plug-and-play nature and portability make them incredibly convenient for quick checks and routine diagnostics. Furthermore, OBD II generic tools serve as excellent complements to more comprehensive diagnostic systems. In busy workshops, they can prevent bottlenecks by providing a readily available tool for basic tasks, freeing up advanced scan tools for more complex diagnostics. They are also ideal for service writers or personnel who require basic scanning capabilities without needing to perform intricate diagnostic procedures.
OBD II Enhanced: Versatility and Coverage
For workshops servicing a diverse range of vehicle makes and models, a general-purpose enhanced scan tool often represents the most practical investment. These tools are engineered to offer broad vehicle coverage, a critical advantage when a shop handles various brands. Compared to basic OBD II tools, enhanced scanners provide access to a wider spectrum of data through enhanced PIDs and offer a greater degree of control via bidirectional functions. Many also feature advanced capabilities such as graphing live data streams and data logging, which are invaluable for in-depth analysis and identifying intermittent faults. The ability to save and document scan data on a PC is another significant benefit, facilitating record-keeping and report generation.
Enhanced data access becomes indispensable when tackling complex diagnostic challenges. However, it’s important to recognize that the level of enhanced coverage can vary significantly between different scan tools and across different vehicle makes. Some tools excel in specific brands; for example, the Vetronix Mastertech was renowned for its comprehensive GM coverage. When choosing an automotive scan tool in the enhanced category, prioritize tools that offer superior coverage for the vehicle brands you service most frequently. Leveraging resources like online automotive technician networks (e.g., iATN archives as mentioned in the original article, or modern equivalents) can provide valuable insights and user reviews to aid in your selection process. This research is particularly crucial for OBD II enhanced tools due to the inherent variability in coverage and capabilities. For workshops working on both domestic and import vehicles, especially European and Asian brands, achieving comprehensive coverage may necessitate investing in multiple enhanced scan tools, each specializing in particular makes or regions.
Many general-purpose enhanced scan tools incorporate unique features to further enhance their diagnostic utility. Some offer integrated repair information databases, providing real-world fixes and troubleshooting guidance directly within the tool interface. Others may offer OE-level reference data or the option to purchase and integrate original equipment manufacturer software, effectively expanding their capabilities to approach those of a factory tool for specific brands. For specialized diagnostic situations, consider tools with vehicle data logging capabilities or PC-based scanning platforms. Data loggers allow for capturing vehicle data during real-world driving conditions, which is particularly useful for diagnosing intermittent problems that are difficult to replicate in the workshop. PC-based scanners often offer powerful data analysis and visualization features, leveraging the processing power and display capabilities of a computer.
The Necessity of Factory Scan Tools
Even with a well-equipped workshop featuring general-purpose enhanced scan tools, there are scenarios where a factory scan tool becomes indispensable. Experts agree that for technicians specializing in a particular vehicle make, owning both a general-purpose tool and a factory tool is highly advantageous. Factory tools provide unparalleled access to virtually all vehicle systems, including powertrain, body, and chassis, encompassing systems like ABS, transmission, airbag, suspension, and air conditioning. While some enhanced scan tools offer coverage for these systems, the depth and detail of access are rarely comparable to that of a factory tool. For the most intricate and challenging diagnostic problems, a factory tool can be the key to achieving a swift and accurate repair, offering functionalities and system insights unavailable in aftermarket tools.
While factory tools offer significant advantages, skilled technicians can sometimes devise workarounds using enhanced tools and in-depth system knowledge to perform certain tests or access specific data points. However, some diagnostic tests and procedures are simply not possible without a factory tool. Furthermore, even with a factory tool, a successful diagnosis often relies heavily on the technician’s expertise, access to comprehensive wiring diagrams, and a thorough understanding of the vehicle’s system operation. As experienced technicians emphasize, the scan tool is only as powerful as the knowledge and training of the user. Investing in training and acquiring comprehensive repair information, including factory service manuals, are crucial complements to any scan tool purchase, particularly when utilizing factory-level diagnostic equipment. Factory manuals are essential for fully understanding how to leverage the tool’s capabilities effectively during complex diagnoses.
Hardware Platforms: Choosing the Right Interface
Beyond the software and diagnostic capabilities, the hardware platform of a scan tool is also a significant consideration. Modern scan tools offer a variety of hardware interfaces, each with its own set of advantages. When choosing an automotive scan tool, evaluate which hardware platform best suits your working style and environment.
PDA-Based and Mobile Scanners
Personal Digital Assistants (PDAs) and, in today’s context, more accurately, mobile devices like smartphones and tablets, have emerged as versatile platforms for scan tools. These devices, popularized by brands like Palm in the past and now dominated by iOS and Android platforms, can function as scan tools while also offering a wide range of other software applications. Their compact size and portability are major advantages. Modern mobile scan tools often interface with vehicles wirelessly via Bluetooth or Wi-Fi, further enhancing convenience and flexibility. Many scan tool manufacturers now offer mobile apps that transform smartphones or tablets into powerful diagnostic tools when paired with a compatible OBD-II adapter.
PC-Based Scanners
PC-based scanners leverage the processing power, large display, and connectivity of laptop and desktop computers. These systems typically consist of software installed on a PC that communicates with a vehicle through a wired interface. PC-based scanners are particularly well-suited for advanced diagnostics, data logging, and integration with other workshop systems like dynamometers. The larger screen real estate of a PC facilitates the display of extensive data streams, graphs, and diagnostic reports. The storage capacity of a PC also allows for virtually unlimited data logging and archiving of diagnostic sessions. Many PC-based scan tool platforms offer feature-rich software with advanced data analysis, reporting, and database management capabilities, making them ideal for power users and in-depth diagnostic work.
Dedicated Hardware Scanners
Dedicated hardware scan tools are purpose-built diagnostic devices with proprietary hardware and software. Historically, these were the most common type of scan tool. While dedicated hardware tools offer a self-contained and often robust solution, it’s crucial to consider their updateability and long-term support when choosing an automotive scan tool. Older dedicated hardware platforms may become outdated more quickly compared to software-based solutions that can be updated more readily. However, modern dedicated hardware tools often incorporate PC connectivity and features like USB ports, memory card slots, and network interfaces to enhance their versatility and update capabilities. Some advanced dedicated hardware tools, like the Snap-on MODIS series, integrate multiple diagnostic functions, such as lab scopes, digital multimeters (DMMs), and scan tools, into a single, comprehensive unit. Display technology has also evolved in dedicated hardware tools, with newer models featuring color screens and graphical user interfaces that improve data visualization and user-friendliness. Features like graphing multiple PIDs simultaneously and displaying parameter trends are now common in higher-end dedicated hardware scan tools, significantly aiding in diagnostic efficiency.
Price and Investment Considerations
The cost of an automotive scan tool varies dramatically depending on its category, capabilities, and brand. When choosing an automotive scan tool, carefully consider your budget and the return on investment it will provide for your workshop. Entry-level code readers are the most affordable, while factory scan tools represent the higher end of the price spectrum. OBD II generic tools offer a balance of affordability and functionality for basic diagnostics. Enhanced scan tools typically require a more significant investment but provide a much broader range of diagnostic capabilities. For enhanced and factory tools, consider not only the initial purchase price but also the ongoing costs of software updates, vehicle coverage expansions, and potential hardware upgrades. Factor in the cost of software modules for specific systems like body controls or ABS, as these are often sold separately. Regular software updates are essential to maintain the tool’s effectiveness with newer vehicle models and to access the latest diagnostic features and repair information.
Ultimately, choosing an automotive scan tool is a strategic decision that should align with your workshop’s diagnostic approach, the range of vehicles you service, and your budget. Carefully evaluate the different categories of scan tools, their features, hardware platforms, and associated costs. By thoroughly assessing your needs and researching the available options, you can select a scan tool or a combination of tools that will empower your technicians to perform efficient and accurate diagnoses, enhancing your workshop’s productivity and customer satisfaction.
Download PDF
